Believe the hype. Woke up the morning of New Year's Eve and couldn't wait to finally check this place out. Got there at exactly 11am but it took them another 15 minutes to finally open the big heavy door blocking the hallway.
Ordered a whole white and whole pepperoni, waited another 35 minutes and finally got to dig in. Just for the record, there were 6 of us so no, I wasn't about to consume 2 whole pizzas all by myself. That would be insane... insanely delicious but insane nonetheless!
I tried the white pizza first and it was pretty freakin' delicious. Great thin crust that wasn't soggy but actually crunchy. The mozzarella and ricotta combination went very well together. All in all, a very good pizza!
The pepperoni was next and it was pretty standard. Nothing too life changing but the crust was still nice and crunchy. The pepperoni was a bit too greasy though, which I normally don't mind too much but after a couple of slices, I had to dab some of the grease with a napkin.
The white pizza would get 5 stars... the pepperoni... 4 stars... if I could give 4.5 stars then I would, but I think a 4 is pretty fair.