Honestly, I have never done any grocery shopping here. I only set foot into AJ's for the Boulangerie or the Food Counter! I've had the caprese wrap and a nice pasta salad to go with it. Amazing! Most recently, I stopped in because it was PI DAY!!! I usually never celebrate it but since it was 3/14/15 (or 3.1415 for all of us math/science nerds) I decided to celebrate. I knew I didn't want any of those frozen or generic grocery store pies so I knew AJ's boulangerie was going to be the winner. I walked out with a slice of peanut butter pie and a slice of key lime pie (my new favorite!) and boy was I satisfied. Both were delicious and I couldn't be happier. The key lime pie was somehow a perfect blend of sweet and tangy and the peanut butter pie was surprisingly not overwhelming at all. They ARE a bit on the sweet side so if you pair it with some tea or some coffee you cannot go wrong!
I will probably be back again. There are more food items that I have to check out and there is a HUGE cheese selection!!!! It IS a bit more on the pricey side so I can't be shopping here on the daily, or even the weekly. But I will be back. I do want to sit out on the patio and enjoy my meal.... or a dessert. =]