Been going to this place since it opened and never disappointed. Yes, you probably won't absolutely love every pie they have as some of them are definitely going to appeal to specific tastes. That being said, if you like desserts, this place is great. Some of our favorites include the Arizona Orange (pretty much an orange version of a key lime), the White Chocolate Raspberry, and also their Black & White. I will be honest that their fruit pies are decent, but I think the cream pies are where they really shine (and are more unique).
Pot pies are also great and can make a nice quick lunch or dinner pick up if you can snag a couple ready to go (tip, you may want to call ahead if it's nearing the 6:30 PM closing time as they are often pretty much sold out of warm pies to go by the end of the day).
Some of the monthly special pies are great also. For instance, we love the boston cream (which just happens to be the pie for August right now).