My wife and I went to chatterpauls for our anniversary. We both found the staff to be extremely professional and the waiters are obviously career restaurant staff and not transient. We started with an amazing amuse-bouche which was curried lamb. We split the lobster bisque which was incredibly tasty with two large shrimp and lobster pieces. My wife had to 10 ounce steak and loved it. I tried it and thought it was very good. The presentation was fantastic with rapini shredded carrots and a mash potato that's probably the best I've tried. I tried the jerk pork chops. I had expected it to be very spicy but found very little heat at all. That said it was still easily the best pork chops I've ever had because it was incredibly tender and flavorful. Our waiter suggested the Petite Syrah from California and it paired nicely with everything. We finished it off with the chocolate cake which was fantastic. They also offered us a smaller creme brulee which is to die for. The only reason I did not give the restaurant 5 stars is because I am comparing it against what I believe are five star restaurants in Toronto. That being said chatterpauls is undoubtedly the best restaurant in Whitby if not the Durham region.