| rev:text
| - I wish that I could say Burgatory is overhyped and unworthy of the always-crowded status, but when it comes to the burgers and shakes, it's fully-deserved. We've only been to this location one time, but if I'm comparing this with the original location, I'd give the nod to Robinson. It's simply more open and the bigger bar gives you better odds of getting a seat, which if you've ever tried to eat at Burgatory, you know is the biggest issue.
First, I have to say that the burnt almond torte milkshake is one of my favorite gluttonous treats ever. In fact, the shakes...in particular, THAT shake...has lured me to Burgatory more than the burgers. I'm particularly fond of their heavy whipped cream and the fact that there's actual burnt almond torte blended in. I personally prefer it sans-alcohol, but the adult version is good. I just think it's better without the vodka. They're special shakes are always tempting, too, but aside from the pumpkin pie, which was awesome, I can't stop ordering the burnt almond torte.
As far as burgers go, I've never had a bad one at Burgatory. I've tried their regular blend, the buffalo, and the elk. All three are simply delicious, with my favorite currently being the elk, cooked medium to avoid the lean meat from becoming too tough. I've enjoyed their burgers as-is from the menu, but if you're not into things like bacon jam and caramelized onion, you can always fill out the custom burger form at the table. Frankly, the burgers themselves are actually good enough that the toppings are totally unnecessary, so I think you're safe either way.
The sides are probably the most underwhelming part of the meal. They just don't standout after such good burgers and shakes. The quinoa was definitely not my favorite dish, but the fries are solid. The onion ring are good, but be warned...the appetizer is a huge order.
Overall, if you're looking for a tasty burger, Burgatory is a great option. I still give my vote to Winghart's if you're just looking for a good burger, but Burgatory is a close second. If you're looking for both a great burger AND a delicious shake, Burgatory can't be beat. Regardless of your appetite, though, there's really no restaurant in Pittsburgh that's worth the wait that Burgatory tends to have after 5 PM. We've resorted to using the No Wait app to see the wait time and get our name on if it's reasonable. Enjoy!
|