After being back quite a few times more for takeout and twice to stay for food and/or drinks, I am disappointed to lower the review even further. Really wanted to love this place because its so cute inside and so close to my house/the perfect spot for happy hour or a chill night out for drinks and dinner. The service at Dive is seriously lacking and inconsistent. Between the grumpy, passive bartender and the waitress that completely neglected the table of my girlfriends and myself one Friday night -- I don't think I can even bring myself to come back and give this location another cent from my pocket.
Their grilled Caesar is absolutely delicious. In fact - probably one of the best salads I've ever had and I get it for takeout at least once a week. Two weeks ago I called to order my regular and their phones were down...Messages saying the line is no longer connected. Last night, I finally got through and went to pick it up and for $14, I had one grilled heart of romaine with half its leaves missing and the takeout container about a third of the way filled with other vegetables. The flavor was good, but carelessly prepared/seriously lacking and it was the final straw for me.
Luckily, I work not far from their location in Wexford so I'll try it there to get my fix. Hopefully I wont run into the same annoying issues