We just came back from Greece & I've been dying for an authentic gyro. We were downtown for the Billy Joel concert, I saw Salonika & had to have it.
I had the gyro special which is a gyro, potatoes & drink. Luckily, they let me swap out their spectacular lemon potatoes that melted in my mouth for the French fries. I had the beef/lamb original gyro. The meat was so tender and tasty. Yum!
My friend really enjoyed the Athena chicken.
They have extremely reasonable prices. There is not much of an atmosphere, but for cheap prices & great food you can deal with it. There is also a bar in the back, which is a bonus. I highly recommend it.