I love finding small, hole in the wall places, and the Pizza Peel fits this description perfectly. We had a large group arrive for a New Year's Day casual dinner. Since there were only about 12 tables in the entire place, we clearly knew where we were sitting.
Service was good, and the beer list, as many have said, was extremely extensive. I believe they have more than 20 beers on tap. Pizza was also good, though not out of this world. The best thing on the menu that night was probably this New Year's Day lucky soup - with chickpeas, collard greens, rice, and bacon - so good.
Take some friends and have some of their delicious pizza and beer.