4.5 stars.
I knew there was an old downtown spot I kept forgetting to review. Which is unfortunate, because the only other Yelper's two stars for this place just ain't right.
Unfortunately it's only open on game nights. But whenever I bring people here on those game nights, it becomes a perfect way to kick off a fun downtown Phoenix evening, for cheap. Does it taste like genuine "Brooklyn NYC pizza"? I don't really care! You stand in a long line along with a bunch of other Suns fans or Dbacks fans or confused cold-state tourists yip-yapping away about how your team is going to kick the other team's ass (unless you're a Red Sox, Yankees or Cubs fan of course, since the Dbacks routinely pound those teams into the Arizona pavement). When it's your turn at the counter, you order one or two slices of pizza, grab a beer on the way to the cashier, then sit at one of the high tables indoor or outdoor, right on the corner of Washington and 1st. You can then continue to yip-yap while also people-watching and beer-drinking and pizza-munching. So what's wrong with that?