For me - I dig this place. Cigar Room.
Funny thing is I went by here for at least a year or 2 before it was open when I came by. Maybe 2 years ago I kept going by but it was always closed. Well I finally hit it last year with an old buddy, PHiL Q while in town. Mind you this is for the Cigar bar - Loved it. There are so many cities that don't have something like this anywhere. And this is done well - great cocktails, good smokes, and we shared some apps.
I don't think anyone is walking in here thinking it's going to be cheap. It's not and it's also not that dive bar that patted me down for a gun! a few blocks away when I stopped in for a beer! I don't mind and come prepared to have some nice drinks and good conversation.
I hope Pittsburgh never loses this gem.