I came here my second time on a Saturday righting between the lunch and dinner rush, hoping for a lull in terms of seating and business- no luck. We weren't fighting for a table but it was still hoppin!
When you come in it can be easy to hold up the line if you don't know what you want, so be sure to be considerate of other people behind you. I ordered the Defalco's mac and cheese- a classic. It may or may not be laced with crack, because it may be the best Mac and cheese I've ever tried. The tables are surrounded by racks of Italian groceries so there is a kitschy intimacy to it.
Overall- great food at a slightly above average price, homey environment, and good environment!