I have to agree with Stephanie T here. I visited Casanova Brothers a couple weeks ago in hopes of finding an authentic NY pizza. I was born and raised in NJ so I know a good pizza, plus I was in NY a couple weeks ago as well so I craved a good slice.
I ordered a pie to go and Tony noticed I was a new customer and introduced himself to me and shook my hand. He was the nicest guy! I had huge hopes for this place because the staff was so friendly.
Don't get me wrong, the pizza didn't taste bad. It just wasn't the taste I wanted. I don't find this pizza close to NY pizza. The garlic knots I could go without. I got them for free so I can't really complain. They were indeed chewy and bland and the sauce didn't do much for them. And it's weird that you need to microwave them.
I wouldn't go out of my way to suggest this place, but I say give it a shot and judge for yourself.