I tend to either have the stuffed grilled cheese, the applerum burger, or their Friday fish fry each time I come (or carryout from) here. My favorite item has to be the stuffed grilled cheese sandwich, which is smothered with fresh veggies and layered in melted cheddar and swiss. Truly think it's the best stuffed grilled cheese in all of Madison.
Alchemy also has a signature jalapeƱo jam that is so delicious with their sweet potato fry appetizer. A real bonus is that you can purchase a jar of this jam for only 5 bucks. I have like 60.
Definitely my favorite spot to frequent. Although quite small and sometimes crowded I have not once been disappointed with taste, atmosphere, or service. If I could give more than five stars I would.