Tasty pizza, but hardly supreme.
We ordered a 12 inch thick crust double bacon cheeseburger pizza, and paid about $15. The crust was thick, soft and tasty, but the sauce seemed to be straight tomato paste with no seasonings aside from an excessive amount of oregano. They were stingy on the meat, to the point that we had to hunt for the bacon and even the hamburger seemed overwhelmed by the flavors of oregano and pickles (yes, they put pickles on their cheeseburger pizza).
I enjoyed the food, but there are a lot of pizza places in Madison, and you can get better food for less at most of them.