I chose McCall's because of the great online reviews. I was more impressed with the décor - comfortable overstuffed booth seating, rich dark wood, ambient lighting - than I was with the food.
I ordered the seafood trio (crab cake, butter poached petite lobster tail, and shrimp scampi). At $42.00, the trio is extremely overpriced considering it isn't served with any accompaniments. I ordered buttermilk mashed potatoes for an additional $6.00. The crab cake was the best of the trio but would have been better if it wasn't served on a bed of overdressed cole slaw. The lobster tail was overdone and underseasoned. The shrimp scampi was overdone but seasoned well. The mashed potatoes were good and tasted homemade.
McCall's is a good place for special occasions if you want to splurge. Perhaps the steaks and poultry dishes are better choices from the menu - most of them are served with chef's accompaniments for the same price as the seafood items.
Would I go back if I'm in Vegas again? Probably not considering there are hundreds of other options to try.