5* for two reasons.
1) they have some of the best fried seafood in town. Whaler = 1 lb of fried fish in a sandwich. SO much fish that you can't really eat as a sandwich. Fried oyster and fried soft shell crab are my other favors.
2) good deal on live lobster. I check their website weekly, and their lobster can be as low as $6/lb. Yes, you have to do the killing at home, but it is live lobster.
Other things are ok too, I buy their spare ribs often. Live oysters are $1 each (DIY openning). ANd they have a new fresh orange juice machine to make orange juice. Love their carb selections too (snow, king crab leg, Dungeness)
Wholey is my seafood go-to in the Burgh, unless i am getting sushi-graded tuna / salmon.