I have given this hotel only three stars but it does have some positive poings, to whit:
Great people, very friendly, very helpful
Good beds
Location, location, location. Walk to the ballpark. Walk to the Rock and Roll HOF, across the street from the Cathedral, 5 minutes from great dining on 4th and Euclid (including LOLA which I have reviewed).
However, the place is crowded, dont even think about getting breakfast in the common room, they have Pepsi (yuck) and not Coke.
Rates are reasonable.
Deserves maybe 3.5 stars.