Perhaps 3.5 rather than 4.
I've eaten here a few times as well as the one at the Premium Outlets & I can say I favor Decatur more.
Been here both lunch and dinner. Selection is more extensive than the Outlet location. Same food but more to choose from. Sushi and entrees are delicious, from seafood to meats to soups and rice. Always warm and they're very quick to replace something.
Dessert could be better though. I mean quality over quantity but I'd love to have more choices to choose from rather than just ice cream or fruit or 2 kinds of cake.
I'm a fan though, price is comparable to some AYCE sushi joints, but with Makino you get that plus more!