Visited Wed May 31 group of 4.
I had originally made a reservation for 10, but only 4 people in my party showed up. They get an extra star for apologizing to me when I called them about the way they applied the auto-gratuity.
Pros
Had the cider and the sheppherd's pie which was pretty good.
Cons
Everyone in my group was charged an auto-gratuity of 21% on our bills!!! The server just added this gratuity without our consent to everyone's bill, even though we were only a party of 4. I understand the server needs to make money because it was originally 10 people on the reservation, but this was a very dishonest way to make money. When I made the reservation there was no mention of this auto-gratuity of 21% for groups of larger than 8. The server did not mention this to me when we arrived, or when she calculated our bills. I would have been happy to pay this if I was informed when we sat down, and if she remind me as I pay my bill. I was going to give her a good tip anyways because the service was great.
A special thank-you to Alyse the manager for acknowledging this mistake, hopefully the manager will address this with the specific server so that this does not happen again.
Protip - The 2nd floor at the back there are two benches that are group for groups of up to 10 people.
Damage - $25 after tax before tip.