Popped in for dinner on our way back from Century III area. Parking lot relatively full. Place was busy - usually a good sign. In this area, this mean's the food is either good or cheap - sometimes both.
We were seated right away - hostess was friendly. Noticed that the day we were there it was $5 burger night, but we decided to use the Enjoy Coupon we had. I ordered a ginger ale - thought the price was a little steep at $2.50 but then again it was unlimited refills. My date had a Sam Adams seasonal draft - $4.00; price would be OK if we were in downtown Pittsburgh.
I ordered the Hot Roast Beef sandwich with a side of fries and a side salad (2 sides come with the meal). Sandwich was OK - more than enough beef on two slices of Texas-sized bread. Brown gravy at least tasted homemade - no lumps. Fries were served on a separate plate - I had asked for gravy on the fries but our waitress forgot. She had no problem running back to the kitchen and loading them up with some gravy. Salad was OK - just be aware that they charge another $0.65 for the hot/cold homemade bacon dressing - something I think the waitress should have told me.
My date ordered the Carriage Inn Sirloin. Cooked to her liking (medium rare), it was pretty tasty. She also ordered the cole slaw (OK) and the zucchini fries (also not bad).
As for the service? Fantastic. Our waitress stopped by several times to check on us. Not only that, but other waitresses stopped by, took our plates when we were finished, and I think the manager also stopped by a couple times to check on us.
After the coupon tax and tip, total bill was around $33. Food was OK - we both gave it a solid 3 stars. Big question is - would we go back? Sure, why not? No reason not to, plus there were some other things on the menu we'd like to try.