We ordered from Day One Pizza during a football game. We got a Columbus salad, Chicken Wings, and a Buffalo Chicken Pizza. All of the food was good, not great. We have no complaints, but weren't blown away.
We were also bummed that they don't have buffalo wings, only honey glazed bbq wings that were a little too sweet for our taste. The BBQ chicken pizza was pretty good, but I don't know if it was worth the price.
Sun Prairie has better pizza places.