Great coffee, easy to find a place to sit and the staff is always very friendly. We keep going back and waiting for that moment when everyone finds out about this little cafe and we can no longer find a seat, but so far it's been our go to coffee shop in Madison.
The coffee comes from KinKin - Johnson Public House's roasting arm, and it's always very good. (I'm not sure if the espresso is from KinKin as well...). The baristas are always very friendly and they can pull a mean shot of espresso. Seating is currently pretty easy to get, and they've laid out the cafe to have a lot of small tables and a variety of seating areas.
The only challenge is parking. Only on street parking is available, and it seems like that block of East Washington gets congested with construction vehicles pretty regularly.