Pier W had been on my bucket list for a few years, so I chose it for my 40th birthday dinner with girlfriends. Our evening was such a disappointment - the view isn't quite as breathtaking when the first person who greeted us, the hostess, is condescending. The Saturday night piano music was lovely, my tempura battered walleye was good but not amazing (too greasy, but the tartar sauce and the soy dipping sauce were amazing). My friends grilled walleye was overdone so she sent it back. Our server agreed it looked overdone, had her transfer it to a side plate, then brought her a new meal by the time we'd finished. She still paid for her dinner but he allowed us a dessert on the house. The peaches and cream cake we chose was divine - so we ended on a high note. Overall, for a renown restaurant with these prices, I expected a better overall experience.