I am not sure why this restaurant was featured on a prominent TV show. The pizza was very good, as were the meatballs. But I think that people who rave about this place really haven't had a wide sampling of great pizza. I thought the pepperoni would be out of this world, but it was just slightly above average. For Cleveland, this is a gem. I definitely respect the locals who have loved it for decades. Try it, it's good. 4 is generous.