Wow!!!
This is the best ice cream I have ever had - seriously, folks, this place shows Sweet Republic who's boss. The ice cream is rich and creamy and full of flavor. I tried the butter pecan, banana, peanut butter and chocolate. The chocolate was unlike any chocolate ice cream I have had before - you could actually taste the coco flavor and it was more satisfying than a sugar loaded Hershey's concoction. Bonus - they have pretzel cones!! This went especially well with scoops of chocolate and peanut butter! Yum!!
I hopped on the froyo train for awhile there, but this place is going to cause me to derail and get fat. Oh well. I'll be happy.
The interior is a very cute, old-school ice cream parlor. It reminded me of Smeeks. There was not seating inside, but about 5 tables outside. They also have lots of retro candies and freshly baked cookies and complimentary water in a jug (flavored with lavender and lemon).
I've already forgotten that Mary Coyle's is closing down...