We got the Fatty Daddy--it was VERY tasty, but it was like our 3rd choice.
I made the mistake of falling in love with some of the flavors and macaron combinations I saw on Yelp and Instagram, and almost every kind I wanted was out of stock. Such a letdown! We ended up picking something my husband and I could agree on since we made the trip out there, but I wasn't in love with it. The woman working there was kind enough to offer samples and apologized for not having the kinds we wanted in stock (totally understandable), but it's hard to justify anything above 3 stars due to the limited choices we had relatively early in the afternoon on a week day.