You would think Jesus was making your pizza from all the other reviews.
My guess is, you will absolutely love it there. I don't like it it. The pizzas are incredibly small for the price and there are better pizzas to be found right here in Phoenix that are less expensive and you won't have to wait a few hours to eat.
The pizza itself is fine, it's not horrible or anything but it most certainly doesn't live up to the hype. The small space and huge demand means the tables are very close to each other. If you are looking to a semi-private conversation over dinner, this isn't the place. I suspect that to a lot of people there is a charm with the social interactions between the tables, just know that going in.