3.5 stars
I've tried two sammies from here. The first one had cookie dough ice-cream in-btwn a cookies & cream cookie. The second one had butterscotch ice-cream in-btwn a salted chocolate cookie. Both were topped w/ chocolate chips.
As mentioned by another yelper, their cookies are a hit or a miss. The cookies & cream one was soft & moist, but the salted chocolate was dense & dry. The latter was probably left out for too long. There is an option, however, to bake your own there to guarantee a soft cookie. Taste-wise, I prefer the cookies & cream over the salted chocolate b/c it's less generic.
As for the ice-cream, they were nothing special. But what bothered me was that they kept running out of flavors when they don't even have that many to begin with. I do appreciate that the ones I had weren't overly sweet though. And they give you a thick slab of it.
Overall, the Red Bench is close-by so I'll probably come again, but I wouldn't go out of my way for it.