Ok. So it's about time for this update.
I finally made it to the top of turtlehead about a month after my initial review and have since been up there several times.
It really is a strenuous hike, but the view up top and rewarding feeling of accomplishment that comes along with it is addicting and keeps me coming back for more.
I've decided there is no "right" way to hike to the top, there are just hard and harder ways to get up there. Being a person who likes maps and rules and designated walkways, it's hard for me, but I make it. I still believe the path could be better marked. I think there are only like, all of maybe 3 trail makers the entire time.
First time I made it to the top, there was a mini American flag and container with the notepad you can sign and couple other goodies. Over the summer and a few months later, the flag is gone but the container was still there last time I went up.
This hike is not for the timid or faint of heart. Wear sunscreen and pack tons of water. And know it really will take up a few hours of your day. But it's worth it when you get to the too! Just remember to save energy for the way down though!