Aroma still remains the best coffee shop in that part of the Annex. It's delicious, has great food options, and a vibe that you simply don't find elsewhere.
They expanded it a bit and added a huge mirror to one wall, so it looks gigantic but also slightly confusing. Don't walk into the mirror. (Just sayin'.)
There are always missed connections posted on Craigslist for this place. Maybe you'll go and fall in love twice in one night.