As the only cigar bar in Madison that I know of, they are my go to spot for cigars. I'm an 'every once in a while' cigar smoker, probably averaging 2 to 4 in a year.
From what I know about cigars (which isn't much, hah!), they have a great selection. I like that it's not just about cigars, you can get a great cocktail (or beer) too!
The atmosphere is what you would expect, lots of lounge like couches and inviting for groups of all sizes. On this visit, we enjoyed their patio seating and took in the great Madison night under the stars.