Had a few things with the best being average and the worst being a little below. Maybe 2.5 stars but I guess two fits since "Meh. I've experienced better." is exactly how I felt the whole time.
Chips / Salsa / Guac: Salsa was fine, guac was alright... I mean it at least looked like real guac. Didn't really taste that great though, but not awful.
PB & J: Looked really good, sauce was good, meat really dry. Overall not very good.
Carne tacos: ... They were pretty bad : soggy, average flavor, meat was really fatty. Looks like online they talk about the chef who worked at The Mission setting up the menu here. Makes sense, since The Mission steak tacos are pretty terrible too.
I was looking up local reviews online to try and see what they all ate that they thought was so great and came across that this place was created by some of the owners of Macayo's. The only thing I can think of that explains the rave reviews is that these people must have a lot of friends/connections.
I might come back one more time and try something else just to feel like I've given it a fair shot.