Great pizza at The Cosmo! It's on the third floor, around the corner from Holstein's... in sort of a hidden alleyway. It's not so "secret" anymore because it seems like everyone knows about this place now.
I tried the white pizza, pepperoni, and the sausage/banana pepper pizzas. My favorite was definitely the white pizza. Who can resist white sauce, ricotta cheese, and GARLIC on pizza? It was also the one that was the least soggy and held up the best. I love myself a thin-crust, firm NY-style pizza. At $5 it's really pricey for just a slice of pizza though.
I will be back (again and again and again!).