First time, just came from lunch there (Fri. - 12/28/12) and was pleasantly impressed. However, as many others have alluded to is the pricing. 2 of us - we had the appetizer of fried tomates (4 slices), burger (make your own), seafood gumbo - soup special, brownie to go and one coffee. The total was $40, without tip.
Tomato appetizer was very good but considerably overpriced ($7) for 4 slices. Thankfully there were two of us so we each got two thin slices.
Seafood gumbo ($7) was very tasty, good seafood taste with a bit of spice.
Burger (arond $12?) was excellent served with the sweet potato fries.
Brownie (average size - around $3-$4?) to go was tasty as was the coffee (gingerbread) I had there.
Noticed they had a special pannani that caught my eye - tuna with wasbai mayo and cheddar with fries. Waitress said the cost was $16.
Overall quality was very good but I also keep in mind that we are talking about a storefront cafe here. That's just a little too much to pay regularly based on my pricbook for a storefront type of place. I understand I am paying for local and organic but it just seems a little too high.
Service was very good. Empty at 11:30 but totally filled when we left at 1:00. I will go back albiet not rushing back and I will certainly buy one of the Yelp coupons to defry $10 from the bill. If our meal was $30, I feel it would have been well worth it and I would have rated this 5 stars.