Chaya is good. The fish is fresh, the prices are reasonable (I definitely wouldn't call it pricey), and the service is very nice. All around a pleasant dining experience. Five stars... not quite, but a decent four. I think my expectations were set too high after reading all these reviews, because I just wasn't as wowed as I thought I'd be. The entire time I was eating I wanted the sushi to have just a little bit more flavor, but it didn't quite get there. Kind of like when you think you're about to sneeze but then you don't. Anyway, I recommend Chaya for good sushi, but not for great sushi. Great sushi will have to wait for a trip to the east or west coast.