Best ice cream sandwich I've ever had! I tried the cinnamon toast and peanut butter and jam flavors. The cinnamon toast has a really strong cinnamon taste, but I still prefer the pb and j - it is so creamy, and goes really well with the oatmeal and peanut butter cookies. I do suggest splitting the sandwich with a friend, cookies are huuuuge. Be prepared to wait in line though - this place is popular!