this place is right between the 2 and 3 stars. Ahh Yelp limitations!
We got married in Blowing Rock, and the Six Pence there is legendary for saving me with a late night salmon BLT, or for hosting my entourage in our quest for last minute liquid courage before the big event. That site is smaller, but the food is much better.
This Six Pence has an extraordinarily great structure - much larger area, separate bar area to keep the noise confined, and everything is nice new wood. It's a treat. The food, however - my salmon BLT was not what I had fallen in love with in Blowing Rock. The food was uninspired - the big bacon strips were good, hard to mess those up...
We did the groupon, so the price ended up being fair. Without that I might have had more of a beef.