Not bad for the price - but not too great either. My biggest pet peeve was the bathroom - no fan, no window - thats just not right. Staff was very friendly and was accommodating to some special requests that I had. Food in the restaurants was pretty good, and I am a VERY selective eater. NYNY draws a mixed crowd - the occasional drunken group from Excalibur that I could do without, and a few early morning jackass drunkards - but yes, you are in Vegas.
SIDE NOTE - the 'free' wifi is paid for by the RESORT fee which is not included in the room rate. Also included is gym access but most people in that place have never found it.