After reading all the positive reviews, I was very disappointed when we had dinner here. Service was marginally acceptable, though slow and we often had to flag down the server.
I had Chicken of the Angels, and it was VERY salty. It was supposed to be served over mushrooms and artichokes, though my meal had one piece of one artichoke! The side of asparagus were ordered to shared was ice cold - and barely enough for one person.
One person in my party ordered a steak medium (pink) and it was definitely well done. The baked potato was huge, and ice cold on the inside but steaming on the outside.
At a restaurant like this (and for these prices) I shouldn't have to ask for a wine list, and the server should ask if we want a second round of drinks.
Although this place is "historic" I think there are far better restaurants in town.