Only oysters I've had in Toronto were from Rodney's and these are definitely par for the course.
The fries are crazy good with their lime aioli, the steamed clams were killer with the broth, and of course all the oysters were fantastic.
We had to try their deep fried panko crust oysters, the Cascumpec Bay oysters from PEI, Beach Angel oysters from BC,Wiley Point oysters from Maine, La St.simon oysters from New Brunswick and Copps Island oysters from Conneticut.
They're all great but the Beach Angels were my favorite for sure.
All oysters come with a side of horseradish of course and a choice of a red wine vinegar base sauce, a traditional seafood sauce and a chipotle base sauce.
I would say Oyster boy has better service than Rodney's, but I would say Rodney's has the better food. May just have to eat at both places back to back to properly compare, which I wouldnt mind at all.