You know how some bars have an odd assortment of appetizers for people to munch on? Things like picked eggs, turkey gizzards, etc... Things you might not eat if you hadn't just put a few beers down? My buddy ordered the turkey gizzard one night. Expecting a horrible slimy taste, it was actually a chewy, salty, a unique taste that can be described as similar to a strong chicken broth. Then our friend brought some back to our house and tried to make our high-school aged babysitter eat them. She won't babysit for us anymore. True story.
Seriously, though. This place is awesome. The cheese curds are the best in Wisconsin. I still haven't found a better draft beer selection in Madison. That said, cheap PBR on tap? Count me in. I still haven't found a bad thing on the menu.
Only downside is unless you're an early bird special type, prepare for a wait. This is where that huge draft beer selection plays in their favor.
There's not much else to say that other reviewers haven't said. Other than you need to be here. And eat turkey gizzard. Just don't push your babysitter to eat them later.