I'm not a fan of buffets in general. I just can't eat my money's worth. I found the buffet to be pretty good value for the money you spend. Seems like the strategy is to focus on quality than large selections (plus for me). I spent my time eating crab legs, oysters, shrimp (ie. the expensive stuff). Some of my friends got the meat (they said the prime rib was salty but other meats were good) and I tried the cake desserts and I thought they were horrible. All in all, for the $40 range for dinner, I think it's top 3.