Well worthy of 5 stars.
I stopped in today for lunch thanks to searching 'food nearby' after an oil change.
I had The Polpette which had (sauceless) meatballs, garlic seasoned peppers topped with parmesan cheese. It was extremely filling and absolutely delicious.
The shop is in a school building that closed in the 60s. Dining area is in the 1st grade classroom and kitchen is in the former 3rd grade classroom. They kept the cool touches like a chalkboard (the menu is on the board) & exposed brick. Service was friendly.
The shop is a little tricky to locate with Google maps, but once inside you'll enjoy yourself