I've had the cupcakes here, and I could take them or leave them. On a tip from a friend, I got the salty caramel ice cream. Heaven. I will never go back to ordering cupcakes here.
The atmosphere is the definition of twee, which I actually don't mind, but some people are put off by it. I've also never been served promptly here, which seems a bit crazy since they aren't making anything that complicated. Put the cupcake on a plate, scoop the ice cream into a bowl.
5 stars for the salty caramel ice cream, 2-3 stars for everything else.