Pretty cool addition to Elizabeth. Ben G. said it best - its a combo of Common Market & Dean & DeLuca. I showed up for lunch one day when I was looking for a quiet - yet kid-friendly place where I could potentially Pinterest while eating. Earl's met all my needs.
I had a tough time deciding what to eat, but after perusing the menus I chose a meatball sub and a can of Le Croix. You order & pay at the same place, so be prepared with your drink & sides when you order your food - that caught me off guard even though they had a sign there.. blonde moment.
While eating, I sat within view of the ice cream cooler and a display of fun drinks, it was very tempting and I definitely had to go research exactly what churro ice cream was - maybe next time, that meatball sub was delicious and left me stuffed!
On a nice day, I bet Earl's is a great place to sit out on the sidewalk, or just inside when they open the giant doors.
Pro tip: there is an entrance in back as well.