Maybe it's because I live here but I can't see what the big deal is about The Old Fashioned. The food IS good but is it really two-hour-wait good? Cheese curds: tasty but soaked in oil. I can't eat more than a few before I get a stomachache. The specials are meh, the beer list is awesome and the service is touch-and-go.
Verdict: Come here if you've got a few hours to kill.