I love going to this place when I'm visiting Willoughby. It's my dad's favorite sub shop and now mine as well.
Not too "froo-frooy" on the toppings, it is pretty much standard lettuce, onion, pepper, Havarti, pepper jack etc, but they load it up and the dressings are really good.
I also really liked the anti pasta salad, never had anything like it before, all cheesy, meaty and spicey.