Tried the restaurant for the first time yesterday with my husband's family. They lived in NY before so they have tried the restaurant in NYC and they enjoyed their pizza a lot so we decided to give it a try here in Scottsdale too. We were a big group of 8 (inclusive of 2 children) so we were offered the private room which was fine with us.
The private room was set up in less than 5 min and we wee called in. Our waitress soon came in and introduced herself and took our drink orders. When she came back with our drinks, we placed our salad orders as well as our mains.
The salad came out in a reasonable amount of time. I ordered the House salad and so did my mother in law. Although we placed our order at he same time, it took at least 5 min or more for her salad to come out. We were surprised why it took so long between the two! Never mind though. The mains to follow compensated for that.
Our order for mains was 3 pizzas, 1 cheese, 1 veg and 1 special (artichoke with Kalamata olives). Out of all three, our fav was the third one. Very tasty and fresh, what differentiates their pizza from other places is the fact that they cook it on coal! Very yummy idea!
All in all, service was great, food was tasty and atmosphere was nice! 4 rather than 5 stars? One needs to be super impressed before throwing in that last super star ;)
Recommended and will be going there again!