5 star desserts and coffee. And check out those hours on the website! They actually stay open late enough to serve the Squirrel Hill Theater movie crowd.
Fresh, delicious cookies and such (oh, Alfajores!), tasty sandwiches on great bread and even an informative binder about the food and beverages and where they come from and why it all tastes so good.
So, for the love of all that is tasty and good, do NOT go to Starbucks. Try something new, become a regular.
Note: the hot chocolate is not great. That's sad. Hence the 4 stars.