I was able to sample many menu items on my first and only visit to Delmonico's to date. The things I loved were the Parmesan chip appetizer, the caesar salad, the soft shell crab and the BBQ shrimp app. The Caesar salad was probably the best I've ever had. The chips were thin cut and perfectly crispy. The BBQ shrimps were cooked just right and the bbq sauce was mild and great for the shrimp. The crab was excellent - perfectly cooked and had great flavor. I also tried the NY strip, it was cooked correctly and had a nice crust. It was not the best steak I've ever had, but you can tell it was done with care and quality. The appetizers were very good because each one had something that made it special...I would like to see that with the steaks as well. I would say the service is what i was most disappointed in. Not that it was bad, but it just wasn't what you expect from a place of this caliber (and price).